The ideal property was yours. There were five other aggressive bidders. But in a spur of moment, you gave your agent authorization to make an offer that was $30,000 higher than the listing price. It was accepted. And you’ve won the bidding war.
However, after two weeks of waiting, your lender comes back with devastating news. Your property was appraised for $40,000 less than the accepted offer. The transaction falls through, putting both the earnest deposit and your dreams into jeopardy.
This scenario plays out for many real estate buyers across America today. Despite the ability to win bidding wars in such a competitive real estate market environment, their deals end up falling apart because of low appraisal value.
It’s one of the most crucial concepts that must be understood in today’s hot real estate market.
The Emotional Buyer vs. The Calculating Appraiser
Bidding wars are human-driven.” Fear, desperation, lack of supply, and FOMO cause the participants to bid on figures far beyond that of any rational market value.
Appraisers, however, don’t give a damn about your feelings. The mortgage lender pays an appraiser to assess the Fair Market Value (FMV) of the property using objective criteria.
To an appraiser, your decision to pay an additional $30,000 for the property is irrelevant. All they consider when evaluating the property is “comps,” which include recent comparable sales. The neighbor just sold their house for $400,000. It would be extremely rare if the appraiser assessed your very same house at FMV of $450,000.
A lender uses this conservative figure as a safety measure. Lenders would never finance your mortgage with anything that exceeds the FMV of the property.
Understanding the Dreaded "Appraisal Gap"
A situation where a property appraised at less than the negotiated price of acquisition will be referred to as “appraisal gap.” An appraisal gap is a financial disaster for an unprepared buyer.
For instance, you might bid $500,000 for a particular property, but upon appraisal, the property is valued at $460,000. The maximum amount the bank can finance will therefore be $460,000.
Where does the remaining $40,000 come from? You should be prepared to provide it.
Unless you have the ability to provide an additional $40,000 in cash in addition to your initial down payment and other settlement expenses, the bank cannot finance the loan. No financing means no transaction, and the property goes back into the market.
How to Save the Deal (And Your Wallet)
If you find yourself facing a low appraisal after a heated bidding war, the deal isn’t automatically dead. Experienced real estate professionals use several strategies to keep the transaction alive:
Renegotiate with the Seller: This is the most common solution. The seller knows that if they put the house back on the market, the next buyer’s lender will likely run into the exact same appraisal issue. Often, a seller will agree to lower the price to match the appraisal, or the buyer and seller will meet somewhere in the middle.
Leverage Your Appraisal Contingency: A standard appraisal contingency gives you the legal right to walk away from the deal with your earnest money intact if the home under-appraises. It is your ultimate safety net.
Challenge the Appraisal: Appraisers are human and make mistakes. If your real estate agent can find better, more recent comps that the appraiser missed, you can request a “Reconsideration of Value.” While not always successful, it is a viable path if the initial report was genuinely flawed.
The “Appraisal Gap Guarantee”: In hyper-competitive markets, buyers sometimes write offers explicitly stating they will cover any appraisal shortfall up to a certain dollar amount (e.g., “Buyer agrees to pay up to $10,000 above appraised value”). This makes an offer incredibly attractive to sellers, but you must have the liquid cash in the
Join The Discussion